Compliance

NYC Local Law 144 in plain English, for teams using AI interviews

Kevin Minn, Founder and CEO, Motium
· 7 min read
Key points

New York City's Local Law 144 is the best-known law on AI in hiring, and one of the most misquoted. This is what it actually says, taken from the law and the city's own rules, and what it means if you use AI interviews.

This is a plain-English summary, not legal advice. Check your own situation with a lawyer.

NYC Local Law 144 and AI interviews: the short version

The law took effect on January 1, 2023. The city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) began enforcing it on July 5, 2023.

What counts as an automated employment decision tool

The law defines it as a computational process "derived from machine learning, statistical modeling, data analytics, or artificial intelligence" that "issues simplified output, including a score, classification, or recommendation," used to "substantially assist or replace discretionary decision making" for employment decisions.

DCWP's rules narrow "substantially assist or replace" to three cases. A tool is covered when you:

  1. rely only on its output, with no other factors considered; or
  2. use its output as one of several criteria, but weight it more than any other criterion; or
  3. use its output to overrule conclusions from other factors, including human decisions.

Two details matter for AI interviews. Transcription alone does not count: the rules say simplified output does not include tools that "transcribe a video or audio interview." Scoring and ranking do count. And it applies at any stage of hiring, not only the final decision. It does not apply to sourcing, only to assessing people who applied.

The bias audit

An "independent auditor" must do it, and DCWP does not approve auditors. Someone involved in building, using or selling the tool, or employed by you or the vendor, is not independent. The audit must be no more than one year old when you use the tool.

The audit calculates selection rates (or, for tools that give scores, the rate of scoring above the median) and impact ratios by sex, by race and ethnicity, and by the combination of both. It uses historical data, or test data if there is not enough history. Guessing people's race or sex from their names or photos is not allowed.

Before you use the tool, you publish on the employment section of your website the date of the latest audit, a summary of the results, and the date you started using the tool. Keep it up for at least six months after you last use the tool.

Two points people get wrong. First, the employer is responsible, not the vendor. A vendor can pay for an audit you rely on, but the duty is yours. Second, the law does not require any particular action based on the results. Other anti-discrimination laws still apply.

Notice to candidates

Candidates who live in New York City must be told at least ten business days before the tool is used, and told which job qualifications and characteristics it will assess. You can post the notice on your careers page, put it in the job posting, or send it by mail or email. Website notice does not have to be specific to one job.

The notice must include instructions for requesting an alternative selection process or an accommodation. Here is the part most summaries get wrong: the rules say nothing in them "requires an employer or employment agency to provide an alternative selection process." You must explain how to ask. Accommodation duties come from other laws, such as disability law.

Penalties

Up to $500 for a first violation, and for any other violation on the same day. Between $500 and $1,500 for each violation after that. Each day a tool is used in violation is a separate violation, and each missed notice is a separate violation. Candidates also keep their right to sue.

How it is being enforced

Quietly, so far. In December 2025 the New York State Comptroller published an audit of DCWP's enforcement (report 2024-N-6). It found DCWP received only two complaints between July 2023 and June 2025, that most test calls to 311 to report a problem never reached DCWP, and that where DCWP found one compliance issue across 32 companies, the auditors found at least 17. DCWP generally agreed with the recommendations. Expect enforcement to tighten, not loosen.

Does this apply to Motium?

It can. Motium gives scores for six areas and a recommendation, which is the kind of output the law describes. Whether it is covered for you depends on how your team uses it, under the three cases above. A person always makes the decision in Motium, and there is no overall score, but if your team in practice relies on Wren's recommendation alone, that use could be covered.

The honest answer for a New York City employer is to treat it as covered. Motium has not yet had an independent bias audit. That is on our list, and we will publish the summary when it is done. Until then, if you hire for jobs in New York City, talk to us before you use Motium for those positions.

Other laws to know

How Motium handles notice, consent and the record is in how Motium uses AI in hiring.

Sources

Questions people ask

Does NYC Local Law 144 require an alternative to the AI tool?

No. The notice must explain how to request an alternative or an accommodation, but the city's rules say nothing in them requires an employer to provide an alternative selection process.

Who is responsible for the bias audit?

The employer or employment agency. A vendor can commission an audit, but DCWP says employers are ultimately responsible.

What are the penalties?

Up to $500 for a first violation and same-day violations, then $500 to $1,500 for each later violation. Each day of use in violation is a separate violation.

See a full Motium interview in under three minutes.Watch the demo

Keep reading

AI in hiring

How Motium uses AI in hiring, and where it stops

An AI hiring tool where a human makes the decision: what Motium's AI interviewer does, what it never does, what candidates are told, and the signed record.

October 31, 2026 · 5 min read
Comparisons

AI interviewers compared: formats, hiring systems, languages and who decides

The best AI interviewer for hiring depends on four things. We compared Alex, BrightHire, HeyMilo, HireVue, micro1, Paradox, Ribbon and Motium from their own websites.

November 12, 2026 · 7 min read